Baseball's Timeless Veterans: 10 'Old Guys' Who Still Have Game
Baseball has a special place in its heart for the seasoned veterans, those players who’ve aged alongside us, becoming familiar faces in the sport’s ever-evolving landscape. These ‘old guys’—a term of endearment, of course—bring more than just nostalgia; they carry experience, wisdom, and a unique perspective that only years in the game can provide. But here’s where it gets controversial: Are these veterans still worth a spot on the roster, or is it time to make way for the next generation? As the Hot Stove season heats up, let’s explore 10 veterans aged 38 and older who might still have something left in the tank. (Each player’s 2026 seasonal age is noted in parentheses.)
Paul Goldschmidt (41): Just three years ago, Goldschmidt was crowned NL MVP with the Cardinals, a career highlight that could one day land him in Cooperstown. After two more solid seasons in St. Louis, he had a quietly effective year with the Yankees in 2025, posting a .731 OPS in 146 games. While he’s no longer the superstar of his prime, Goldschmidt could be a reliable one-year stopgap at first base, where his four Gold Gloves speak volumes. And this is the part most people miss: For teams that missed out on Pete Alonso, Goldschmidt might be the next best thing.
Chris Martin (40): Martin’s journey is nothing short of remarkable. Debuting at 28 with the Rockies in 2014, he even spent two years in Japan before becoming a bullpen stalwart. Over 10 seasons and 418 games (all in relief), Martin has consistently delivered. His 2.98 ERA with the Rangers last year was just the latest example, following a 1.05 ERA with the Red Sox in 2023 that earned him AL Cy Young votes. The question remains: How much longer can he keep defying the odds?
Andrew McCutchen (39): McCutchen’s return to Pittsburgh in 2023 was nothing short of inspiring. The 2013 NL MVP and franchise icon has spent the last three seasons with the Pirates, remaining one of their most consistent hitters—though that might say more about the team’s offense than his current prowess. McCutchen has expressed interest in returning, but his future remains uncertain. One thing’s for sure: If he’s not ready to hang up the cleats, neither are we.
Tommy Pham (38): It’s hard to believe Pham turns 38 in March. After a 2025 season where he avoided the trade deadline for the first time since 2021, Pham remains a valuable bench bat with occasional power and a solid .330 OBP (15 points above the MLB average). His goal of reaching 200 home runs and 200 stolen bases might be a stretch, but his personality and grit make him a fan favorite. The real question: Is there room in today’s game for a player like Pham?
David Robertson (41): Robertson’s career is a testament to longevity. Twice the Yankees’ closer, including the daunting task of succeeding Mariano Rivera, he took a step back in 2025 to focus on tennis and farming before joining the Phillies’ bullpen in August. With a 3.40 ERA in 43 postseason games, he’s a proven playoff performer. But here’s the kicker: Will he prioritize baseball or his newfound passions in 2026?
Carlos Santana (40): A 16-year veteran with a Gold Glove and Silver Slugger to his name, Santana’s career is oddly undersung, with just one All-Star appearance in 2019. Known for his patience at the plate (1,330 career walks, 40th all-time), he struggled in Cleveland last year before a late-season stint with the Cubs. The intriguing part: If he returns and draws one more walk, he’ll pass Hall of Famer Tim Raines on the all-time list.
Max Scherzer (41): Scherzer’s 2025 regular-season stats might suggest he’s on the decline, but his October performance reminded everyone why he’s a legend. With nearly two decades as one of the most intimidating postseason pitchers, Scherzer’s competitive fire remains unmatched. The debate: Is he worth another contract, or is Father Time finally catching up?
Justin Turner (41): Turner had his least productive season in years with the Cubs, hitting just .219 and barely featuring in the postseason. Chicago declined his option, sending him back into free agency. Yet, Turner has a history of silencing doubters. The burning question: Can he bounce back in 2026, or is this the end of the road?
Justin Verlander (43): Verlander’s quest for 300 wins is well-documented, but after just four wins in 2025, he’s still 34 shy. Despite this, he posted a respectable 3.85 ERA and dominated in September with a 2.08 ERA. The controversial take: Could he pitch into his 50s to reach his goal? Or is it time to let the dream go?
Kirby Yates (39): Yates was lights-out in 2024, making his second All-Star Game and finishing eighth in NL Cy Young voting with a 1.17 ERA and 33 saves for San Diego. However, his 2025 season with the Dodgers was marred by injuries and a 5.23 ERA. The key issue: Can he stay healthy in his late 30s, or is his best baseball behind him?
Final Thoughts: These veterans represent more than just stats; they’re the heart and soul of the game. But as teams look to the future, the question remains: Do these ‘old guys’ still have a place in the modern MLB? What do you think? Are they worth another shot, or is it time to pass the torch? Let us know in the comments!
